Is Producing Electronic Music Difficult? A Comprehensive Guide

Electronic music has been one of the most popular genres in the music industry for decades. With the advent of technology, producing electronic music has become more accessible than ever before. However, the question remains – is producing electronic music hard? In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the ins and outs of electronic music production, the challenges that come with it, and the skills and knowledge required to succeed. Whether you’re a beginner or an experienced producer, this guide will provide you with valuable insights and tips to help you navigate the world of electronic music production. So, let’s dive in and discover the answer to this question!

Quick Answer:
Producing electronic music can be both challenging and rewarding. It requires a good understanding of music theory, as well as proficiency in using electronic music production software and hardware. Additionally, producing electronic music requires creativity and the ability to experiment with different sounds and techniques. While it can be difficult to master, there are many resources available to help producers improve their skills, including online tutorials, music production courses, and community forums. Ultimately, the difficulty of producing electronic music will depend on the individual’s skill level, experience, and dedication to learning and improving.

What is Electronic Music Production?

Definition and Brief History

Electronic music production refers to the process of creating music using electronic devices, software, and hardware. This can include a wide range of genres, from techno and house to ambient and experimental.

The history of electronic music production dates back to the early 20th century, with the invention of the first electronic musical instruments in the 1920s. However, it wasn’t until the 1960s and 1970s that electronic music began to gain mainstream popularity, with the advent of synthesizers and other electronic devices.

Today, electronic music production is a thriving industry, with a wide range of software and hardware tools available to producers. From digital audio workstations (DAWs) to virtual instruments and effects plugins, there are countless options for creating and manipulating electronic sounds.

Despite the abundance of tools and resources available, electronic music production can still be a challenging and complex process. From mastering the basics of music theory to navigating the vast array of software and hardware options, there is much to learn for aspiring electronic music producers.

Types of Electronic Music

Electronic music production encompasses a wide range of genres, each with its unique characteristics and production techniques. Some of the most popular types of electronic music include:

  1. House: This genre originated in Chicago in the 1980s and is characterized by a 4/4 beat, a bassline, and a melody. House music can vary from deep and soulful to energetic and techno.
  2. Techno: Techno emerged in Detroit in the late 1980s and is generally produced for playback by DJs in clubs or raves. It typically features a repetitive, mechanistic beat and a dark, futuristic atmosphere.
  3. Electro: Electro music originated in the 1980s and is characterized by its use of synthesizers and electronic sounds. It often incorporates elements of funk, disco, and hip-hop.
  4. Trance: Trance music emerged in Europe in the early 1990s and is characterized by long, evolving tracks with a strong emphasis on melody and atmosphere.
  5. Dubstep: Dubstep originated in the UK in the late 1990s and is characterized by its heavy basslines and intricate production techniques.
  6. Hip-Hop: Hip-hop music emerged in the Bronx in the 1970s and is characterized by its use of MCs, DJs, and beatmakers. Hip-hop can vary from boom-bap to trap and mumble rap.
  7. EDM: Electronic Dance Music (EDM) is a broad range of percussive electronic music genres made largely for nightclubs, festivals, and raves. EDM is generally produced for playback by DJs who create seamless selections of tracks called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called a mix, called

Equipment and Software Required

Producing electronic music requires specific equipment and software to create and produce high-quality music. Here are some of the essential equipment and software needed to get started:

Hardware

  1. Digital Audio Workstation (DAW) – a computer-based software that allows the music producer to create, record, edit, and mix music.
  2. MIDI controller – a device that allows the producer to input musical information into the DAW, such as notes, pitches, and timing.
  3. Audio interface – a device that connects the MIDI controller to the computer and enables the transfer of musical information between the two.
  4. Microphone – for recording vocals or acoustic instruments.
  5. Studio monitors – for playing back the music and hearing how it sounds.
  6. Cables and connectors – for connecting the equipment together.

Software

  1. DAW software – such as Ableton Live, Logic Pro, or FL Studio, which are used to create, record, edit, and mix music.
  2. Virtual instruments – software versions of real instruments, such as synthesizers, pianos, and drums, which can be used to create sounds and melodies.
  3. Effects plugins – software that can be used to add effects to the music, such as reverb, delay, and distortion.
  4. Sample packs – collections of pre-recorded sounds and loops that can be used to add variety and depth to the music.

Having the right equipment and software is essential for producing high-quality electronic music. However, it’s important to note that the cost of this equipment and software can vary widely, and some producers may opt to start with more affordable options before investing in more expensive gear. Additionally, there are many free and open-source software options available that can be used to create electronic music, although these may have limitations compared to paid software.

The Learning Curve

Key takeaway: Producing electronic music can be challenging, but it can also be a rewarding experience. Aspiring electronic music producers need to master the basics of music theory, sound design, mixing, and mastering. Additionally, building a home studio and collaborating with other artists can help producers gain recognition and improve their skills.

Understanding the Basics

Producing electronic music can be a daunting task for beginners, as it requires a good understanding of the basics. This section will cover the fundamentals of electronic music production that one needs to master before diving into more complex techniques.

1. Introduction to Electronic Music Production

Electronic music production involves the use of technology to create music. The technology can range from basic software such as a digital audio workstation (DAW) to complex hardware synthesizers and effects processors. It is essential to understand the different types of equipment and software used in electronic music production.

2. Understanding Audio Signals

To produce electronic music, one needs to understand how audio signals work. An audio signal is a series of sound waves that are recorded and processed to create music. Understanding the basics of audio signals will help you understand how different effects and processes can be applied to your music.

3. Recording and Editing Audio

Recording and editing audio is an essential part of electronic music production. Recording involves capturing audio signals into a DAW, while editing involves manipulating those signals to create a final product. Understanding the basics of recording and editing audio will help you create high-quality recordings and make your music sound professional.

4. Mixing and Mastering

Mixing and mastering are the final stages of electronic music production. Mixing involves balancing the different elements of a song, such as the bass, drums, and melody, to create a cohesive mix. Mastering involves optimizing the volume, EQ, and stereo image of a song to make it sound polished and professional. Understanding the basics of mixing and mastering will help you create music that sounds great on any system.

Overall, understanding the basics of electronic music production is crucial for anyone looking to create their own music. It may seem overwhelming at first, but with time and practice, you can develop the skills needed to produce high-quality electronic music.

Building a Home Studio

Building a home studio can be an intimidating task for those who are new to producing electronic music. It requires a significant investment of time, effort, and money to acquire the necessary equipment and software. However, with the right guidance and resources, it is possible to create a functional home studio that can produce high-quality electronic music.

One of the first steps in building a home studio is to identify the essential equipment and software needed to produce electronic music. This includes a computer or laptop, a digital audio workstation (DAW) software, a MIDI controller, audio interfaces, studio monitors, and various cables and connectors.

Once the necessary equipment has been identified, the next step is to set up the home studio. This involves installing the DAW software, configuring the MIDI controller, connecting the audio interface to the computer, and setting up the studio monitors. It is essential to ensure that all the equipment is properly connected and functioning correctly before starting to produce music.

After the home studio has been set up, the next step is to learn how to use the equipment and software effectively. This involves learning how to use the DAW software, understanding how to use the MIDI controller to input notes and control parameters, and familiarizing oneself with the studio monitors and how they affect the sound.

It is also important to consider the acoustics of the room where the home studio is located. This includes factors such as soundproofing, reducing external noise, and controlling the reflection of sound off walls and floors. A well-designed home studio can help to create a better listening environment and improve the overall quality of the music produced.

Finally, it is important to remember that building a home studio is an ongoing process. As technology evolves and new equipment becomes available, it may be necessary to upgrade and improve the home studio to keep up with the latest trends and techniques in electronic music production.

In conclusion, building a home studio can be a challenging but rewarding experience for those who are interested in producing electronic music. With the right equipment, software, and knowledge, it is possible to create a functional home studio that can produce high-quality electronic music.

Learning from Online Resources

The digital age has made it easier than ever to learn the craft of electronic music production. With a wealth of online resources available, producers can now access a wealth of knowledge and tools to help them get started on their musical journey. Here are some of the ways in which online resources can be leveraged to enhance one’s electronic music production skills.

Online Courses and Tutorials

One of the most popular ways to learn electronic music production is through online courses and tutorials. These resources provide step-by-step guidance on various aspects of music production, from the basics of MIDI and audio recording to advanced techniques like sound design and mixing. Some popular online platforms for learning music production include Udemy, Coursera, and Skillshare, which offer a wide range of courses and tutorials on music production and related topics.

Forums and Communities

Another great way to learn electronic music production is by joining online communities and forums. These platforms provide a space for producers to connect with one another, share knowledge, and ask questions. Many forums also have sections dedicated to specific topics, such as sound design or music theory, making it easy to find answers to specific questions. Some popular forums for electronic music production include Reddit’s r/electronicmusic and the VST-based r/vstforum.

YouTube and Video Tutorials

YouTube is a treasure trove of electronic music production tutorials, covering everything from software tutorials to in-depth lessons on music theory and composition. Many popular YouTube channels, such as Flam3, Patreon, and MakeNoise, offer free and paid content that covers a wide range of topics. In addition, there are many YouTube channels dedicated to software-specific tutorials, such as Ableton Live, Logic Pro X, and FL Studio, making it easy to find answers to specific questions.

Social Media Groups

Finally, social media groups, such as Facebook groups, can be a great way to connect with other producers and learn about electronic music production. Many groups are dedicated to specific topics, such as music production or sound design, and provide a space for members to share tips, tricks, and resources. Additionally, many social media groups offer regular meetups and events, providing opportunities for producers to network and learn from one another.

Overall, online resources offer a wealth of opportunities for producers to learn electronic music production. Whether you prefer structured courses or more flexible learning environments, there is something for everyone. So, whether you’re just starting out or looking to take your skills to the next level, don’t be afraid to explore the vast world of online resources available to you.

Mastering the Craft

Developing Your Unique Sound

Developing a unique sound is one of the most challenging aspects of producing electronic music. It requires a deep understanding of the different elements that make up the genre, as well as the ability to experiment and push boundaries. Here are some tips to help you develop your unique sound:

  1. Experiment with different genres and styles: While electronic music is a broad genre, there are many sub-genres within it. Experimenting with different styles can help you find your own sound. For example, you could try blending elements of techno, house, and ambient to create something new.
  2. Use unconventional sounds and samples: Electronic music is all about using unconventional sounds and samples. Try using field recordings, found sounds, or even random noises to create something unique.
  3. Pay attention to the details: The smallest details can make a big difference in electronic music. Pay attention to the sound design, mixing, and mastering to create a unique and polished sound.
  4. Collaborate with other producers: Collaborating with other producers can help you learn new techniques and approaches to producing electronic music. It can also help you develop your unique sound by bringing in new ideas and perspectives.
  5. Don’t be afraid to fail: Experimentation and failure are essential parts of the creative process. Don’t be afraid to try new things and fail. It’s all part of the journey towards developing your unique sound.

Collaborating with Other Artists

Collaborating with other artists can be a great way to improve your skills as a producer and to gain exposure for your music. By working with other musicians, you can learn new techniques, get feedback on your work, and expand your musical horizons. Here are some tips for collaborating with other artists:

  1. Choose the right collaborators: It’s important to choose collaborators who complement your skills and style. Consider reaching out to producers or musicians who have a similar sound or approach to music as you.
  2. Communicate effectively: Good communication is key to any successful collaboration. Make sure to communicate your ideas clearly and listen to your collaborators’ feedback.
  3. Be open to new ideas: Collaborating with other artists can be a great opportunity to try new things and push your creative boundaries. Be open to new ideas and approaches, and don’t be afraid to experiment.
  4. Establish clear roles and responsibilities: To ensure a smooth collaboration, it’s important to establish clear roles and responsibilities for each collaborator. This can help prevent misunderstandings and ensure that everyone is on the same page.
  5. Be flexible: Things don’t always go as planned in the world of music production. Be prepared to adapt and make changes as needed to ensure the success of the collaboration.

By following these tips, you can make the most of your collaborations and improve your skills as a producer.

Networking and Gaining Recognition

As an electronic music producer, it is crucial to understand the importance of networking and gaining recognition in the industry. Building relationships with other producers, DJs, and industry professionals can help you to learn from others, gain access to resources, and ultimately further your career.

One way to network is by attending music events and festivals, where you can meet other producers and industry professionals. These events can also provide opportunities to showcase your music and gain exposure to potential fans and industry professionals. Additionally, social media platforms such as Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook can be useful tools for connecting with other producers and industry professionals, as well as promoting your music.

Another way to gain recognition is by submitting your music to blogs, podcasts, and radio shows for consideration. This can help to increase your exposure and reach a wider audience. Additionally, participating in online communities and forums dedicated to electronic music production can also help you to connect with other producers and gain recognition for your work.

Overall, networking and gaining recognition are crucial aspects of building a successful career as an electronic music producer. By building relationships with other industry professionals and promoting your music, you can increase your chances of success in the competitive world of electronic music production.

Challenges in Electronic Music Production

Balancing Creativity and Technical Skills

Creating electronic music can be a challenging process that requires a delicate balance between creativity and technical skills. On one hand, producing electronic music demands a certain level of technical proficiency in using digital audio workstations (DAWs), understanding music theory, and working with various synthesizers and effect plugins. On the other hand, it also requires creativity and the ability to craft unique and original compositions that stand out in a crowded and competitive field.

Balancing these two aspects can be difficult, as the technical side of music production can be time-consuming and overwhelming for beginners, while the creative process can be frustrating when faced with limitations imposed by one’s technical abilities. However, finding a balance between the two is essential for producing high-quality electronic music that stands out in the genre.

One way to achieve this balance is to start with simple and intuitive software, such as GarageBand or Ableton Live, which have user-friendly interfaces that make it easy to create and experiment with different sounds and arrangements. As one’s technical skills improve, they can then move on to more complex software and hardware, such as synthesizers and drum machines, to further expand their creative possibilities.

Another way to balance creativity and technical skills is to focus on learning the basics of music theory and composition, such as chord progressions, melody, and harmony. This knowledge can help producers make more informed decisions about the sounds and arrangements they choose, as well as provide a solid foundation for creating original and memorable compositions.

In conclusion, balancing creativity and technical skills is a crucial aspect of electronic music production. While it can be challenging to find the right balance, with dedication and practice, producers can develop the skills and knowledge needed to create high-quality electronic music that stands out in the genre.

Staying Up-to-Date with Technology

Producing electronic music requires a significant amount of technical knowledge and proficiency in various software and hardware tools. One of the biggest challenges in electronic music production is staying up-to-date with the latest technology.

The world of electronic music production is constantly evolving, with new software, hardware, and tools being released on a regular basis. Keeping up with the latest technology can be a daunting task, especially for those who are just starting out in the field.

However, staying up-to-date with technology is crucial for electronic music producers, as it allows them to take advantage of the latest tools and techniques to create the best possible music. It also helps them to stay competitive in the industry and to meet the demands of listeners who are always looking for new and innovative sounds.

There are a number of ways to stay up-to-date with technology in electronic music production. One approach is to regularly read industry publications and blogs, which can provide information on the latest trends and tools. Another approach is to attend music production workshops and conferences, where experts share their knowledge and experience with the latest technology.

In addition, many electronic music producers turn to online communities and forums, where they can connect with other producers and share tips and techniques for using the latest technology. These communities can also provide valuable feedback and support, helping producers to improve their skills and to stay on top of the latest trends in the industry.

Overall, staying up-to-date with technology is a critical challenge in electronic music production, but it is also an opportunity for producers to enhance their skills and to create the best possible music. By taking advantage of the latest tools and techniques, producers can set themselves apart from the competition and establish themselves as leaders in the industry.

Overcoming Writer’s Block

Writer’s block is a common challenge faced by electronic music producers. It can be a frustrating experience, feeling stuck and unable to produce new music. However, there are several strategies that can help overcome writer’s block and get back on track.

  • One strategy is to take a break and come back to the project later with fresh eyes and a clear mind. Sometimes, stepping away from the project for a while can help you come up with new ideas and perspectives.
  • Another strategy is to try a different approach. If you’re stuck in a rut, try experimenting with a new software or hardware, or try a different genre or style of music. This can help you break out of your comfort zone and come up with new ideas.
  • Collaborating with other producers can also be a great way to overcome writer’s block. Bouncing ideas off of other people and getting feedback can help you come up with new ideas and approaches.
  • Lastly, it’s important to remember that it’s okay to have a bad day or a creative dry spell. It’s all part of the process, and it’s important to be patient and persistent. Keep working, and eventually, the ideas will come.

Summing Up the Key Points

Electronic music production is a challenging endeavor that requires a significant amount of technical knowledge, creativity, and persistence. The following are some of the key points to consider when it comes to the difficulties of producing electronic music:

  • Technical Skills: To produce electronic music, one must have a good understanding of music theory, sound design, mixing, and mastering. This requires a significant amount of time and effort to learn and master these skills.
  • Creativity: Producing electronic music requires a high level of creativity and originality. It can be challenging to come up with new and interesting sounds, melodies, and arrangements that stand out in a crowded market.
  • Hardware and Software: To produce electronic music, one needs access to high-quality hardware and software. This can be expensive and requires a significant investment of time and money to research and purchase the right equipment.
  • Production Workflow: Producing electronic music involves a complex production workflow that includes recording, editing, mixing, and mastering. Each of these stages requires a significant amount of time and effort to get right.
  • Marketing and Promotion: Once the music is produced, it needs to be marketed and promoted effectively to reach a wider audience. This requires a good understanding of social media, music distribution, and other marketing channels.

In summary, producing electronic music is a challenging process that requires a significant amount of technical knowledge, creativity, and persistence. It is not a task for the faint of heart, but for those who are passionate about music and dedicated to their craft, it can be a rewarding and fulfilling experience.

The Rewards of Electronic Music Production

Producing electronic music can be a rewarding experience for many reasons. Some of the rewards of electronic music production include:

  • Creative freedom: Unlike traditional instrumentation, electronic music production allows for a high degree of creative freedom. With electronic music, you can create any sound you can imagine, limited only by your own imagination and technical skill.
  • Immediate feedback: Electronic music production software often includes features that allow you to hear your music as you create it. This immediate feedback can help you make adjustments and refine your sound quickly and efficiently.
  • Cost-effective: Compared to traditional instrumentation, electronic music production can be a cost-effective way to create music. With a computer and some software, you can produce professional-sounding music without the need for expensive instruments or recording equipment.
  • Collaboration: Electronic music production software often includes features that allow for collaboration with other musicians and producers. This can help you learn from others and improve your skills.
  • Flexibility: Electronic music production is highly flexible, allowing you to create music at any time, in any place, and with any device. This flexibility can help you balance your music production with other aspects of your life.
  • Opportunities for exposure: With the rise of digital music platforms, electronic music producers have more opportunities than ever before to get their music heard by a global audience. This can lead to new opportunities for collaboration, performance, and even commercial success.

Overall, the rewards of electronic music production can be significant, making it a rewarding and fulfilling experience for many producers.

Final Thoughts and Encouragement

Producing electronic music can be a challenging yet rewarding experience. Despite the obstacles that one may encounter along the way, it is important to remember that these challenges can be overcome with patience, persistence, and dedication.

  • Embrace the learning process: Electronic music production is a vast and ever-evolving field, and there is always something new to learn. Rather than feeling overwhelmed by the amount of knowledge required, embrace the learning process and enjoy the journey of discovery.
  • Seek out resources and community: There are countless resources available online, from tutorials and courses to forums and social media groups, that can provide valuable information and support. Additionally, connecting with other electronic music producers can provide valuable opportunities for collaboration and feedback.
  • Don’t be afraid to experiment: One of the most exciting aspects of electronic music production is the ability to experiment and push boundaries. Don’t be afraid to try new things and explore different techniques and sounds.
  • Stay motivated: Producing electronic music can be a long and sometimes challenging process, so it’s important to stay motivated and focused on your goals. Whether it’s setting short-term milestones or celebrating small victories, find ways to stay motivated and inspired throughout the creative process.

By keeping these final thoughts and encouragement in mind, aspiring electronic music producers can approach the creative process with confidence and enthusiasm, and overcome any challenges that may arise along the way.

FAQs

1. What skills are required to produce electronic music?

Answer:

To produce electronic music, one needs to have a good understanding of music theory, a basic knowledge of audio engineering, and proficiency in using music production software. Additionally, having an ear for music and creativity are also essential skills. With practice and dedication, anyone can learn to produce electronic music.

2. How much time does it take to learn how to produce electronic music?

The amount of time it takes to learn how to produce electronic music can vary depending on the individual’s background and dedication. Some people may be able to produce basic tracks within a few weeks, while others may take several months or even years to develop their skills. The key is to practice regularly and seek out feedback from others in the electronic music community.

3. What equipment is needed to produce electronic music?

To produce electronic music, you will need a computer with music production software, a midi controller, and a set of speakers or headphones. Additionally, you may want to invest in other equipment such as synthesizers, drum machines, and effects processors to expand your sound palette. The type and quality of equipment you need will depend on your budget and the style of electronic music you want to produce.

4. Is it necessary to know how to play an instrument to produce electronic music?

No, it is not necessary to know how to play an instrument to produce electronic music. Many electronic music producers use software instruments and samples to create their tracks. However, having a basic understanding of music theory and being able to play an instrument can be helpful in creating more complex and interesting arrangements.

5. Can I produce electronic music on my smartphone?

Yes, it is possible to produce electronic music on a smartphone using music production apps such as GarageBand, FL Studio Mobile, and Beatmaker. While the functionality and quality of these apps may be limited compared to desktop music production software, they can still be used to create basic tracks and develop your skills as a producer.

How hard is it to produce electronic music today?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *